Bard’s lawyers had argued that when FDA reclassified intravascular filters as Class II devices, the agency’s special controls for such devices provided preemption against lawsuits for Bard’s G2 IVC filter. A U.S. District Court judge in Arizona should have granted Bard’s summary judgment motion involving Sherr-Una Booker’s lawsuit, Bard said.
The 9th Circuit disagreed in the opinion it handed down yesterday: “We assume, without deciding, that the special controls are requirements, but we nevertheless conclude that they are not ‘specific’ requirements ‘applicable to a pa…